–D.N. Rodowick, The Virtual Life of Film



I’d like to begin by thanking Scott Dunham and the Doc Film Series at the University of Chicago for inviting me to speak a little with you this evening. This opportunity is something of a dream come true. I have said in the past, with only slight exaggeration, that I wrote a whole book on Paul Thomas Anderson’s films just so I could write one chapter on Punch-Drunk Love. Punch Drunk Love is today the “forgotten” Anderson film (not counting his modest first effort, Hard Eight)—the one that slipped in the cracks between Boogie Nights and Magnolia in the 1990s and then the sustained critical success of There Will Be Blood a decade later.
When Anderson first told a group of reporters at Cannes in 2000 that he wanted to make his next film with Sandler, he was reportedly laughed at. No serious director would make a formulaic movie with a Hollywood star whose fortune was made playing the King of juvenile humor. Meanwhile, when Punch-Drunk Love finally debuted in late 2002, both Anderson’s cinephile devotees and Sandler’s legion of fans alike were often completely bewildered by a movie that was utterly unlike either Boogie Nights or Magnolia, not to mention—on the other extreme—such bona fide box-office hits as Happy Gilmore, Billy Madison or The Wedding Singer.
I’ve called my talk “The Adam Sandler Art House Movie,” because it nicely encapsulates the contradictions and difficulties in approaching this movie. Punch Drunk Love responds to, and even builds directly off of, the stereotypical roles that Sandler usually inhabits. But, at the same time, it is all presented within an off-beat, challenging, visual and aural style that comes right out of an aesthetic stretching back to the days of the New Wave.
Its also what Anderson himself called PDL in interviews. Critics often read this as implying that the star had been molded into an art house formula, but really Punch-Drunk Love is an exercise in Anderson’s own reinvention of the pre-existing genre conventions in which Sandler thrived.
The film was explicitly written as a vehicle for the star. After Magnolia bombed, Anderson had a falling out with New Line, who had produced both that film and Boogie Nights while giving him unprecedented freedom. Anderson was able to do PDL because Sandler had a lucrative production deal with Revolution Studios—who let Anderson do what he wanted as long as Sandler was in it. In a way, he was a kind of “hired” hand with the movie—literally brought in by Revolution to shepherd an “Adam Sandler film.” Its the closest that Anderson came to being an old-fashioned Hollywood studio auteur—the kind of filmmaker who works within the pre-existing genre confines and expectations of something like Sandler’s frat-boy mode of comedy.
By that same measure, the notion of Punch-Drunk Love as simply a variation on the “typical” Adam Sandler film also misses so much more—namely, it was also the one most clearly Anderson’s film in its stark cinematic originality. It is here—while ironically working in dialogue with Sandler’s persona—that I would argue Anderson began to fulfill his often premature industrial and cultural claim to auteur status.
Although Punch-Drunk Love references many other styles, films and directors throughout, it is not beholden to any of them. Instead of latching onto the genre of neo-noir, or emulating the look of Scorsese or the scope of Altman, Anderson created something alarmingly original—something that felt unlike anything that either he or anyone else had made before. The initial reaction for some was to hold this against him, as though he was just goofing around with his SNL pals, and thus wasn’t trying hard to do something “profound” or “important,” as he had with Boogie Nights or Magnolia. In retrospect, the film’s unexpectedness is one of Punch-Drunk Love’s finest qualities. As Anderson told The London Times in 2003, this film “came from my stomach. It’s referenceless. When you start out, you latch onto other styles, to help you get across what you’re trying to say. But this one is mine somehow—and I’m proud of that.”
There were many accidental moments in the writing and making of Punch-Drunk Love. At one point early in the film, Egan mumbles that “business is very food,” rather than “good,” when asked by his brother-in-law (Robert Smigel) how things are going with his novelty toilet plunger business. The line was originally a typo when writing the script, but the filmmaker left it in—seeming to intuit that such misspeaking fit the socially-awkward, ill-spoken character perfectly. Later in the film, as a steadicam tracks Barry around his apartment, the frame briefly shakes as the camera bumps the coffee table, after moving in too closely on its subject. The effect was originally accidental—a gaffe that occurred during a test-run of the scene, but Anderson was pleasantly surprised by the jolting effect it created, and thus too left in the mistake on subsequent takes. These unplanned moments in Punch-Drunk Love are not only individually effective, but they also speak to a larger ephemeral aspect of Anderson’s film—a certain sense of unexpectedness. Fittingly, the film’s opening prologue ends on Barry’s pitch-perfect declaration, “I do not know”—an appropriate contrast to the omniscient voice-over in Magnolia’s opening.
On a first look, Punch-Drunk Love does not give its audience as much on the surface—simply the story of an emotionally unstable toilet plunger salesman (Barry) whose verbal abuse from his seven sisters, and a regrettable encounter with a corrupt phone sex line, complicates his newfound romantic relationship with a mysterious woman named Lena (Emily Watson). The first half of the plot largely revolves around Barry’s elaborate plan to expose a flaw in a Healthy Choice food products’ promotional giveaway, in order to acquire free frequent flyer mileage—a plan that works, but not in the timely fashion Barry would have liked. Meanwhile, the second half of the film focuses more on a Utah-based phone sex line that blackmails, and later physically threatens, Barry after he uses the service late one night.
Much is inspired by true stories. A few years earlier, an engineer from the University of California, discovered a loop hole in a Healthy Choice promotion, exploiting a discontinuing line of pudding cups for the individual barcodes. The result was that purchasing $3,000 dollars’ worth of pudding eventually netted him one million frequent flyer miles. Other aspects of the film spoke back to Anderson’s own experiences, which suggest that Punch-Drunk Love is every bit as autobiographical at its core as Magnolia. Perhaps unsurprising, given the unabashed childhood obsession with porn that paid off with The Dirk Diggler Story and then Boogie Nights, Anderson also frequently used phone sex services. Sandler later joked that, for the role, “Paul did all the research for me [. . .] Every time I tried to call him, he’d tell me he was on the other line and asked me to wait for two minutes.”
Like Boogie Nights, Punch-Drunk Love’s plotline highlights the emptiness of the commodified sexual experience, and subsequent guilt involved, while contrasting the “strange and distant” feeling of his passive phone sex activities with the movement towards a more genuine connection with Lena later on. Equally autobiographical is Barry’s large family, dominated by sisters. In real life, Anderson grew up the youngest to three older sisters, though the director has resisted the implication that they’re anything like the verbally and emotionally abusive siblings in the film. Anderson has also conceded that he did, like Barry, struggle with anger issues. The film conveys the futility of such anger, while also resisting easy moments of resolution to Barry’s expressions of violence, which are at times quite shocking. At one point, Barry completely destroys a restaurant bathroom in a scene that took four takes—enough for Sandler’s own hands to start bleeding from the performance.
The intensity of Barry’s violence is one of many ways in which Punch-Drunk Love works beyond its quirky little storyline and operates through a more complicated set of affective registers. At the film’s center, Barry is a likeable, but distant, character, whose anger and social awkwardness keeps audiences at arm’s length, and who inhabits a depressingly barren, colorless urban landscape. The plot goes in seemingly random directions, culminating in an awkward love affair involving a man with serious anger problems and a woman who may well be a stalker, and whose courtship largely involves busted up restrooms, moments of miscommunication, doses of self-loathing, and pillow talk that centers on affectionate descriptions of human mutilation.
Then, as soon as it’s begun, Punch-Drunk Love ends at a very brisk 95 minutes (literally half the length of its predecessor). The audience is left with a touching moment of romantic reconnection that is undermined somewhat by its fleeting nature, the slightly off-kilter emotional states of its two partners, and the larger sense that—in this film—our most intense feelings of affection are as often savage (physically, verbally) as they are reassuring. So, what to make of this “romantic comedy” in the end? Its sincere displays of affection are marred just beneath its surface by a cold, unresolved, vision of a lonely life within an alienating consumer world, and of people’s emotional imbalances, while its considerable humor seems often to instead reflect and reinforce profound feelings of sadness. And, throughout all this, at no point does Anderson cheat narratively or thematically by telling us what to think or feel. There is no “but it did happen;” there are no grand speeches about regret, or not wanting to die.
At the same time, Punch-Drunk Love does share many similarities with Anderson’s earlier films. He returns to a smaller story, focused essentially around one clear protagonist (like Sydney in Hard Eight), while also presenting us with a salesman who seems to be struggling with a sense of his own identity after years of trying to please others, just like Donnie Smith in Magnolia or Buck Swope in Boogie Nights. Centered on a small business owner who’s deeply unsatisfied emotionally by the modest financial success he’s achieved, Punch-Drunk Love is another Anderson movie about isolation and loneliness, about finding a possibly loving environment, amidst the alienatingly bland, materialistic consumer culture of Southern California.
Meanwhile, the film’s playful intensification of Sandler’s persona builds on a similar meta-commentary offered by the performance of Tom Cruise as the hyper-masculine misogynist in Magnolia. The meditation on the nature of a star’s persona, along with the narrative emphasis on a single, violent salesman, will also anticipate Anderson’s next film, the more celebrated There Will Be Blood (2007). Thematically, meanwhile, Punch-Drunk Love continues Anderson’s obsession with guilt, often of a sexual kind, and with characters being forced to pay for mistakes they’ve made in the past. The line uttered to Barry late in the film by his tormenter, Dean Trumbell—“Do you think you can be a pervert and not pay for it?”—could fit just as easily within Anderson’s other films. And, ultimately, Punch-Drunk Love ends on a hopeful note that, as with earlier films, seems complicated by the sense it is fleeting at best. Believing that Barry and Lena will simply live “happily ever after” is a superficial reading that ignores unresolved problems which both of them raised throughout the film.
In closing, the beauty and difficulty of Punch-Drunk Love is that it never really resolved the contradictions of its critical, aesthetic and commercial status as an “art-house Adam Sandler movie”—a perfect description, but one that suggests there was ultimately no easily built-in audience for the film. Instead, the film reveals itself slowly—through layers of irreducible tensions between beauty and violence; bodies in motion and still-framed landscapes; love and anger; harmonious music and unsettling sounds; Jeremy Blake’s stunning artwork and Barry’s barren world; richly intoxicating soundscapes and long moments of awkward silence; and periods of remarkable old Hollywood grandeur disrupted by discordant instances of experimental disruption. Punch-Drunk Love avoids the alternately amusing and horrifying shock value of Boogie Nights, as well as the grand, sweeping emotions of Magnolia. But what it does provide lasts longer, I think—all the more so because this richness is irreducible to such simplistic thematic observations as the historical rise of video, the ephemera of celebrity, being haunted by one’s past, or the serendipity of everyday life.

History is no longer intrinsic to films but extrinsic. The description of effects-driven movies as enclosed and enclosing worlds may seem to remove them from the political analyses of ideology critique. That, indeed, is their purpose: to abstract themselves from the temporal to grasp the eternal.Are we celebrating a film which is the epitome of Hollywood's lack of "historical consciousness"--in every sense of the phrase?

While at Indiana, I retained a passing interest in postmodernity, but there wasn’t a lot of room for it in my coursework, so try as I did to make something more of it, it didn’t take. I really didn’t know where to go with it beyond a certain kind of textual analysis, and such ambitions were further hampered by the fact that anything “postmodern” was toxic for upcoming, younger scholars. By the time I finished writing my dissertation, I had left Jameson’s theories behind—even though, symbolically, the cultural logic of late capitalism was all over the argument (the acknowledgements in Disney’s Most Notorious Film pays perhaps belated reference to Jameson’s influence).
My move to historical-materialist reception studies meant conceptualizing history in a more empirical, objective direction, which at the time seemed somewhat in tension with the more subjective, theoretical flourishes of the postmodern, drawn mostly (for me) from a rich and eclectic group of thinkers such as Jameson, Jean Baudrillard and Roland Barthes. Researching the ugly history of Song of the South’s reception and the civil rights movement was more fascinating than dwelling on the absence of that history in the postmodern era—an argument I still bought, but which seemed somewhat superfluous in the big scheme of things. Like I said, I didn’t know where to go with it—methodologically or institutionally.
I guess another way to put that is highlighting the stigma that comes with even evoking the word “postmodern,” an academic cliché which elicits bemused dismissal at best and active hostility at worst. This is especially sensitive for someone on a job market which seems to prefer reductive labels above all else. There’s no point in bringing in a theoretical tradition—however valid—whose very name will make your academic life harder, not easier. It’s kind of like the cliché of referencing Freud or Lacan—maybe there’s something of substance there, but why bother? There’s got to be a simpler, less antagonistic, way to say it. So I wrote a whole book on Song of the South that’s very much a “postmodern” argument to me, but I don’t once mention that word, or even any theorists associated with it, in whole book (other than the acknowledgements) because I didn’t think it was necessary enough. Postmodernity was not worth the trouble.
Lately, though I’ve been coming back around to it in bits and pieces. For example, a similar issue of a not-postmodern postmodern argument came up in my forthcoming project on Paul Thomas Anderson. I always knew my reading of his body of work was drawing out the ways in which his films themselves articulated a vision of “postmodern” America, but I didn’t bother ever to use that term—let alone flesh out what it meant at length—because it was redundant to the more specific themes I was already highlighting (the social mediation of spectacle, consumer culture, the exchange value of celebrities) . . . . and especially problematic for a book that I always intended as much for a non-specialist reading audience, consisting of cinephiles and film buffs, as for fellow academics who’d put more stock in some form of high theory (even the postmodern) than in authorship.
But as I look ahead to revisions, this matter of the “big picture”—of how to make the book relevant beyond just the self-explanatory analytical framework of examining Anderson’s five feature-length films—the fact of the matter is that I have to do more with it than just another auteur study. Here’s one idea I’ve worked through so far:
“A product of postmodern America at the turn of the new millennium, Anderson’s body of work reveals an evolving, but also strikingly consistent, vision of fractured patriarchy and mediated social relations at the intersection of representation, commodity culture, and the ubiquity of celebrity. While each film speaks to the particular historical and economic exigencies of its production and reception, they accumulatively suggest the traces of an emergent authorship worth a second look.”
Frankly, I worry that this will alienate some of the intended readership for Blossoms & Blood—that some mainstream readers will see the word “postmodern” and immediately think “more academic bullshit.” I suppose that’s what I was fighting in the first place by not being more explicitly theoretical, especially in my introduction (and what I was resisting in the Disney book). But as an academic book, particularly as one rooted in something as academically maligned as theories of authorship, the turn to the postmodern is necessary to give it the intellectual heft required.
But, beyond that, I really do believe that Anderson’s films are about postmodern America in very distinctive ways—mass media’s self-reflexivity, the casting of movie stars, the diegetic role of celebrities, the use of salesmen, the deep sense of alienation, and so forth. I’m not focusing on that because I “have” to in order to make it acceptable to an academic press—I’m sure my initial interest in those films grew out of how they activated pre-existing issues of representation and American consumer culture that I gravitated to in the first place.
So the challenge with rewrites will be to draw out more the postmodern theoretical, cultural and historical contexts surrounding the emergence of Anderson’s films. It is particularly exciting in light of the fact that I’ve never really had occasion to articulate these issues in writing before—namely, the not-insignificant question of how I define a “postmodern” America, from approximately the 1980s on, and how Anderson’s films (as one part of the quasi-indie, “smart” film, movement during the 1990s) reflect a modest but consistently interesting aspect of it.
* * *
The more pressing issue with coming back to the postmodern as a scholar, however, is that I need to find a way to better define myself on the job market. On the surface, my work on Disney, Paul Thomas Anderson, cinephilia, Hawaii, and now digital cinema may not seem to have that much in common. This didn't concern me at first. I consciously fought the need for labels, as I’ve articulated before, but later I gave in and articulated an identity as a “historical-materialist reception studies scholar.” I still embrace that methodology, but the title only makes limited sense without a more explicit acknowledgement of the postmodern as constituting the larger set of cultural issues that I'm approaching through that methodology. In the past year, my tentative work on digital cinema—which didn’t seem to make sense at all without Jameson—and my teaching of basic film history and theory at MSU have really hit home for me how much I read film and media through the postmodern.
Long story short, I think the road through Indiana was a vital step towards fulfilling the intellectual goals I was originally invested in as an MA student--and not a shameful rebuttal to it, as I originally thought. I needed to be a "real" media historian--somebody who made a good faith effort to document past events within well-defined historical narratives, and not just a theorist who referenced history in a generic sense--before I could try to be the kind of postmodern scholar I wanted to be a decade ago. Everything I write comes back to postmodernity—and the next few months will be focused on exploring that more (again) and articulating its significance in my work and in my professional persona.