“If we have to stop making movies that offend anyone, we’ll all be making Disney movies.”
—Coonskin Producer Albert S. Ruddy (1975)
Like many classic Hollywood re-releases, Song of the South had been largely uncontroversial in the 1970s. With a range of contemporary social issues still unresolved, detractors often saw its persistence, at worst, as an unfortunate, but hardly surprising, continuing annoyance from cinema’s racist past. Instead, the racially-charged film that was controversial in the 1970s was the affectively intense satire of Song of the South: Bakshi’s Coonskin. In addition to satirizing Disney, Bakshi’s deliberately shocking representation of life in the inner-city was also a product of, and a subversive response to, Hollywood’s controversial “Blaxploitation” period. This consisted of the numerous studio films, released mostly between 1969 and 1974, that “featured black casts playing out various action-adventures in the ghetto.” Often motivated more by financial concerns than newfound social awareness, these films emerged in large measure from Hollywood’s growing desire to exploit profitable African-American distribution markets. Films like Shaft (1971) and Superfly (1972) offered new cinematic visions of strong, assertive anti-Sidney Poitiers—black stars who celebrated their race rather than minimized it.
Although admirable to the extent that it offered more roles to African-American actors and touched superficially on the concerns of urban life, Blaxploitation also depended upon degrading narratives of murder, drug trafficking and prostitution. Thus, as Ed Guerrero has noted, Blaxploitation also had a contradictory appeal, since it reflected and perpetuated racist white assumptions about the general violence and criminality of black life in the inner-city. Bakshi’s film directly negotiated this contradiction.
Song of the South’s reception history is incomplete without looking at Coonskin. As one of the last Blaxploitation films of the period, Coonskin told the story of Brother Rabbit’s journey from the American South to Harlem to take on an Italian gangster who was ruining the neighborhood. As Michael Gillespie argued, “Coonskin can be thought of as closer to the irrational and transgressive spirit of [the oral slave narrative] Brer Rabbit than has ever been previously imagined.” The film restored Brother Rabbit as a signifier of the black experience (in keeping with its origins), highlighted the grotesqueness of blaxploitation as a genre, and critiqued the ignorant whiteness and sentimental nostalgia of Song of the South.
Although the latter was constructed as a critique of the former, both Song of the South and Coonskin shared quite a bit in common. Both responded to Disney’s legacy and its impact on animation (Song of the South as its affirmation, Coonskin as its rejection). Both reflected childhood memories—the audiences’ own nostalgia with Song of the South and Disney more generally; Bakshi for his own childhood living in a predominately Black neighborhood of Brooklyn and watching Disney cartoons. Both responded to the emergent popularity of Blaxploitation and reflected white visions of the African-American experience. Both worked within, and further perpetuated, cinematic stereotypes of that same experience.
Finally, both Song of the South and Coonskin were criticized upon first release for some of the same reasons. In the mid-1970s, the Congress for Racial Equality (CORE) and other activist groups protested Bakshi’s film, ironically citing very similar criticisms that marred Song of the South three decades earlier. In both cases, detractors saw the film as an offensive white interpretation of African-Americans which traded on grotesque and anachronistic (cinematic) stereotypes of the race. While Coonskin’s cultural and aesthetic satire of Song of the South was valid, its X-rated approach and knowing deployment of racist imagery was not necessarily unproblematic. As a result of this controversy, Paramount dropped the film in late 1974; it was eventually picked up by Bryanston Pictures and distributed as an “exploitation” picture.
Despite an intense amount of media coverage regarding its controversies, Coonskin quickly faded from theatres and public consciousness within a year. Its affective power and grotesque images left those few audiences who finally did get a chance, out of sometimes morbid curiosity, to see the film, feeling generally confused and alienated. Thus, one survived, and one didn’t.
Throughout the 1970s and 1980s, Song of the South’s popularity was often dependent upon the same cultural appeal as Blaxploitation, the two traditions Coonskin brought together. Disney’s nostalgic vision of the American South spoke to the “large, conservative white audience’s [. . .] desire to, at least on screen, suppress the black revolt in all its manifestations and the white liberal-left social and cultural agenda built during the 1960s.” It was this audience that Guerrero identifies as making white reactionary vigilante fantasies like Dirty Harry (1972), Death Wish (1974) and Walking Tall (1974) popular—those films which often featured white cops cleaning up the same criminal urban spaces that Blaxploitation glorified.
Coonskin merged two otherwise incongruent subgenres (Disney animation and blaxploitation) into one deliberately grotesque and incoherent text to show how both rested on racist, and thoroughly cinematic, stereotypes about African-American identity in the 20th-Century. While made for a different time, the reception of Song of the South was no less a response to factors underlining Blaxploitation as Dirty Harry was in 1972. Coonskin’s appearance highlighted the superficially incoherent, but internally logical, cultural sense in which the early 1970s marked the sudden popularity of both Blaxploitation and Song of the South.
Though hardly embraced by the militant wing of the Civil Rights movement, Coonskin’s aggressive, unapologetic style echoed the racial rebellion of the period, while Disney’s nostalgic vision of pastoral simplicity and institutional racism appealed to audiences rediscovering open spaces via the American suburb. Thus, Song of the South’s successful reissue in the 1970s was a cinematic equivalent to the “white flight” which deeply affected American cities. As Guerrero notes, “After years of urban riots and rebellions, shifting demographics accelerated as racial boundaries eroded, and most American cities found whites heading for the suburbs, abandoning city centers and their movie houses to inner-city blacks.”
Both versions of the Uncle Remus tales appeared within the context of Blaxploitation and urban rebellion in the inner-cities, the latter of which was provoked by years of racial tension and existing power structures sympathetic to white privilege. This coexisted with the large scale migration of both white people and civic resources to the suburbs that originally began with the desegregation of public schools in the 1950s. Likewise, Song of the South provided comfort, in the form of outdated stereotypes, to white people who were unsettled by the sudden power, authority and autonomy blacks had struggled to attain in urban centers such as Harlem, Detroit, Los Angeles and the south side of Chicago. These were power centers that fifty years earlier (such as in the Greenwood district of Tulsa) would have been wiped out in a white-instigated race riot.
Yet Coonskin’s understanding of cultural politics and racial representations isn’t simple. Like all Blaxploitation texts, Bahski’s visually and aurally challenging X-rated film can be also read as a liberatory white fantasy of how hopelessly violent and chaotic US urban spaces had become in the aftermath of mass migration to the suburbs. Although the film itself did not appeal to those audiences, controversy around its aesthetic provocation symbolically reaffirmed for white audiences the need to leave the city, reasserting racial order and boundaries. Symbolizing the lack of direction within the Civil Rights movement, liberals and activists argued amongst themselves over the value of Coonskin.
Coonskin’s satirical logic may have shrewdly highlighted how the presence of Song of the South in the 1970s spoke, at least in part, to racist attitudes about American urban spaces. However, the same can be said for Bakshi’s film—Coonskin was made by a white Brooklyn native who had since moved to a trendy and wealthy section of Southern California at the start of his successful filmmaking career. While detractors such as CORE missed or ignored Coonskin’s attempt at satire, the larger concern about the use of racist stereotypes was not without merit.
Reactions to Coonskin’s controversial reception represent one of the earliest shifts in the increasingly revived perception of Song of the South itself. The confrontational presence of Bakshi’s film during 1974 and 1975, its provocative textuality and critical backlash, was eventually appropriated by proponents of Song of the South to deflect attention from, and even validate, the latter.
In nostalgic contrast to Disney’s old film, Coonskin became for fans an example of a truly “offensive” representation when it came to images of African-Americans in film. They contrasted the negative media attention and the verbal and visual intensity of Coonskin’s satire with the popular and politically uneventful appearance of Song of the South a couple years earlier to imply that Disney’s film was harmless, even morally positive, entertainment. Although Coonskin had been intended as a biting indictment of Disney animation, Song of the South and conservative audiences which embraced both, its reception took a much different shape in the long-run.
Writing in the guise of “Thumper” from Bambi (1942), Arthur Cooper addressed a 1975 review of Coonskin to a now-deceased Walt Disney in Newsweek. As with several reviews of the time, he criticized Bakshi’s film as narratively uneven and unfunny. More interesting was how Cooper also deflected attention back favorably to Song of the South. Bakshi, he wrote, has “made Coonskin. It’s got an R rating, which must stand for Ripoff because what he’s done is turn [Disney’s] Uncle Remus stories inside out.” Instead of analyzing Coonskin further, Cooper nostalgically evoked memories of what he saw as Disney’s more innocent version:Last night I watched an old print of your “Song of the South,” with all those cute bluebirds and sharecroppers, and I think I’ll send it to Bakshi. Although there were protests about [Song of the South in the past], in this case CORE ought to just let sleeping dogs snore.
Cooper’s nostalgic lament highlighted how Coonskin had received harsher criticism in the 1970s than Song of the South had. It also foreshadowed how the negative reception of Bakshi’s film was later appropriated to even more conservative ends by supporters of Disney. Cooper’s review offered an early glimpse into how the intensity around Coonskin made the seeming simplicity of Song of the South more appealing to sympathetic critics and fans. In the long run, Coonskin’s reception unintentionally worked in support of the very same film it sought to criticize.
Similarly, film critic and historian Leonard Maltin highlighted the Coonskin controversy in an entry on Song of the South in the second edition of his widely-read book, The Disney Films (1984). Unapologetically reverent, his compilation offered detailed information on the production histories, plot summaries and critical receptions of every major Disney film ever made. For the second edition, Maltin added two sentences on Coonskin to his section on Song of the South:There are still occasional protests [to Song of the South], though the worst of these seems mild compared to the reception given Ralph Bakshi’s live-action/animated Coonskin in 1975—a protest so fiery that the film was disowned by its distributor! Ironically, Coonskin was a modern-day satire based in part on Song of the South.
Maltin did not explain why Coonskin was “so fiery,” or how it was “a modern-day satire” of Song of the South. His reference to Bakshi’s film did little more than deflecting attention away from Song of the South’s past controversies. Disney’s conservative film on the surface is a mild, less overtly offensive, text than Coonskin’s abrasive satire. Yet what gets lost here is that Bakshi’s film was not meant for a child-friendly audience. In fact, Coonskin was meant to provoke.
The intersection of Coonskin, Disney and the legacy of the Civil Rights Movement becomes increasingly entangled here. The effect is that these complicated histories become increasingly distorted through historical revisionism. Maltin’s second edition perpetuated and even solidified several myths about Song of the South—one being that it was always a huge box-office hit in its earlier releases. Another was that criticism of the film was muted overall in 1946, save for “some liberal reviewers and Negro organizations.” Maltin also suggested that:It was only in the 1960s, when Civil Rights became a major concern of the entire United States, that it became clear that Song of the South and films of that kind would be touching sensitive spots if shown again. Even the reissue of Gone with the Wind in 1967 sparked some (relatively minor) protest among certain Negro groups who objected . . . .
However, this is the exact opposite of what happened—the film was most forcefully protested in the 1940s. Yet, in Maltin’s reconstructed timeline, Song of the South’s brief controversy in the “Civil Rights” era of 1960s had been successfully overcome and put to rest. In the 1984 edition, Maltin even reworded one sentence to seem less interested in the conceding the “Uncle Tom” criticism of Song of the South. In 1973, Maltin wrote, “it is difficult to condemn a film of this kind, Uncle Tom accusations notwithstanding, for in spite of its syrupy story line and occasional flaws, Song of the South has some of the most delightful moments ever captured on film.”
In 1984, however, Maltin rewrote this sentence to read, “Accusations of Uncle Tomisms and quibbles over its syrupy storyline are ultimately defeated by the film’s sheer entertainment value.” The difference is perhaps incidental, though no less noteworthy, given that most of the other pages on Song of the South are otherwise identical. Whereas the first edition appears to bracket off the consideration of “Uncle Tom accusations,” suggesting the concerns may have validity, the second edition collapses those criticisms with the other reservations about the film, hence creating the impression that every criticism of Song of the South was overcome by virtue of its affective entertainment. In the context of his second edition, Maltin positioned Song of the South as a happy corrective, as reassurance, to the perceived trauma caused by the controversies around Coonskin.
Just as white opposition increased steadily in the late 1960s and 1970s to the Civil Rights movement, there was another backlash against the backlash to Coonskin. As Maltin and Cooper’s reactions demonstrated, the backlash was not in defense of Coonskin. Rather the controversies around the film were used to deflect the question of racial difference altogether. In the void of liberal disagreements over Bakshi’s film grew an unchallenged conservatism. The criticism of Coonskin was used to implicitly discredit the larger Civil Rights movement for greater equality in cinematic representation. In a review of Daniel Leab’s book, From Sambo to Superspade: The Black Experience in Motion Pictures (1975), Tom Shales commented in passing on the CORE controversy. He noted that “one would think constructive forms of consciousness-raising, if such are possible, would be preferable to coercive tactics such as” CORE’s call for censorship with Coonskin.
He pointed out that around the same time “pressure groups in New York [had] blocked the airing of a public television documentary because they thought it offensive.” For Shales, these were examples of how counter-productive the protests were. He went further, arguing that the notorious radio and later television program, Amos `N` Andy (which was eventually taken off the air because of African-American protests), was “funny” and that “several black celebrities have said they did not find it objectionable.” Shales’ review criticized Leab’s book—which rightly criticized the history of African-American representations in Hollywood—for “righteous indignation” and for demanding too much progress too soon. By “asking a 1949 film to succeed at a 1975 level [. . .],” he wrote, “Leab apparently expects films to reform overnight.” Yet Shales also worked to undermine that same progress in representation by arguing that protest groups (such as CORE) had gone too far. The contradictions of an evasive whiteness begin to reemerge in Shales’ piece—a type of identity which does not proclaim the importance of being white, but rather denies the category of “race” altogether (in the service of white privilege).
Once devised as a particular kind of critique of Song of the South, Coonskin’s failure and de facto censorship became appropriated by Disney supporters as a vindication of the 1946 film’s innocence and entertainment value, and as a deflection from the controversies the earlier movie had incited. In the 1984 edition of The Disney Films, Maltin declared that “Song of the South has triumphed, and survived a period of acute racial sensitivity.”
As framed, “a period of acute racial sensitivity” conflated both the Civil Rights movement in the 1950s and 1960s with the controversy around Coonskin in the 1970s. This conservative denial of race in the 1980s celebrated a triumphal environment in which many whites became less racially conscious, while Civil Rights groups and media critics failed to mount a coherent critique of films such as Song of the South and Coonskin like they had in the 1940s. That progressive failure served those who wished for Song of the South’s survival during “a period of acute racial sensitivity”—a confident assertion particularly appropriate to the anti-Civil Rights movement of the decade.
Subsequently, Song of the South’s racist depiction of the Plantation South, generally agreed upon since the 1940s, became increasingly rejected by fans of the film and supporters of Disney by the 1980s. Sympathizers were emboldened by the controversy around Bakshi’s film, by an increasingly conservative political climate, and by the continuing survival of the 1946 film. Although inaccurate to trace all of this back to the release of Coonskin, negative reactions to that film that also touched on Song of the South almost always invariably reinforced this twisted logic.
The reactions to both films in the 1970s served as sobering touchstones in relation to white America’s decreasingly racial consciousness. When Song of the South reappeared in the 1980s within this new condition of possibility, the film seemed tame, even harmless for many. The film was now as a nostalgic journey from a beloved institution’s past (Disney). Audiences during the emergent “color-blind” 1980s were suddenly quite anxious not to see race, or allow others to see race, in the Disney film. In retrospect, attacks on Coonskin were at least partially misplaced. As Bakshi’s film faded, Song of the South would continue to be far more resilient and insidious—the same sort of evasive whiteness that Coonskin had tried to deconstruct.
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Coonskin, Civil Rights, and the “Period of Acute Racial Sensitivity”
Friday, April 8, 2011
A Few Thoughts on Tron's Blu-Ray Release
Tron: Legacy (2010) made its home video debut on blu-ray and DVD this week. Perhaps more notably, Disney also finally re-released the original Tron (1982) as well. They had earlier passed over the opportunity to re-release it in anticipation of the sequel’s otherwise much-hyped theatrical debut in IMAX and 3D last December. At the time, this led to understandable speculation that Disney was afraid of its own intellectual property. Of course, on the other hand, Disney is notorious for locking up its older titles into the proverbial “Disney Vault,” restricting them to very limited release windows, and ensuring their demand across decades and generations. This is a business model they’ve exploited as far back as WWII, after stumbling upon it out of economic desperation. As recently as two months ago, a second-hand copy of Tron’s first, since discontinued, DVD release (2002) was going for over $100 on Amazon.
Yet this makes Disney’s initial decision all the more curious; it lent further evidence to the idea that the company didn’t want people to actually see the original, for fear it would dampen, rather than heighten, interest in its sequel. While certainly a true cult classic, the original Tron did not connect with most moviegoers in 1982 and certainly has not aesthetically aged well since then, by any standard outside of nostalgia. The fact remains that Tron is one of the most important films ever made in the history of Computer-Generated Imagery, a milestone its knock-off sequel doesn’t come close to matching. Yet that, by itself, doesn’t equal blockbuster franchise material any more than Kubrick’s visually stunning but narratively-incidental 2001 would. This then prompted the even bigger question: why had Disney invested more than $200 million on a potential franchise that was built on the backs of a brand it seemed transparently ashamed of?
I am unabashedly a fan of the original Tron, but that comes with two important caveats. For one, I’m not exactly sure why. I find something truly sublime about the look and feel of the original. If I had to be more specific, I would probably focus on the film’s unintended evocation now of nostalgia for an earlier period—the dawn of digital imagery and the emergence of public arcade gaming, an era that came and went somewhere between the two Tron films. To wit, my favorite scene in the whole sequel has nothing to do with 3D or CGI—it’s the moment where Sam explores the eerily cavernous spaces of his father’s now-abandoned arcade. I think I also find the clean, cool surfaces of the Grid oddly reassuring in its simplicity, rather than alienating as many do.
There is another reservation to my Tron fandom. Even I was sitting in the IMAX theatre last winter and constantly asking myself, “Who was this movie made for?” Tron has a true base of followers, but not enough to justify such a lavish spectacle and considerable investment. Meanwhile, the story’s representation of computer technology was even more naïve and anachronistic than it had been three decades earlier. In every conceivable way, the new Tron surely felt completely nonsensical to anyone without familiarity to the original, which was in itself hardly a paragon of narrative and thematic logic to begin with. Tron: Legacy definitely made money, but relative to its costs and labor involved it probably did not fare much better than the original. Instead, the movie seemed to be another one of those properties that no one really loves, but which nonetheless coasts to decent numbers on the backs of massive hype, a popular soundtrack, and inflated ticket prices. And now that it’s available on home video formats, the most excited people seem to be Best Buy employees anxious for new material that’ll help move the latest High Definition televisions.
Nevertheless, the franchise seems to be moving forward all the same. In a way, Disney seems to be constructing a transmedia franchise in search of an audience. Marvel Comics released Tron: Betrayal in the fall of last year, the latest in several attempts to continue the narrative from the original. A new animated series is headed to the Disney XD cable channel next year. The property continues to lend itself to videogames on home gaming platforms, and rumors persist that a third film is in the works. Indeed, narratively, Tron: Legacy seemed more interested in the future of the franchise than the past.
But this still doesn’t answer the question: why? Why Tron? Why now? Disney’s attempt to build on the technological and theatrical success of James Cameron’s Avatar is one obvious enough reason (and that, ironically, makes it similar to the original’s attempt to tap into the explosion of interest in science fiction after Star Wars). Yet the new marketplace demand for IMAX and/or 3D films still doesn’t explain why Tron was chosen of all possibilities. The answer to this question, I feel, lies in Disney’s larger corporate history of repurposing, recirculation and cross-promotion.
By the end of the 2000s, Disney was moving away from its traditional interest in the Princess narrative, which had been there since almost the beginning (Snow White, Cinderella), but which really didn’t come to dominate the company until the Eisner era ushered in Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast and so forth. Now, in retrospect, it’s impossible to see Disney without it. But this unquestionable stroke of business genius/luck came at a cost—all but the most die-hard of audiences have gradually tired of the same formula. The “Princess” imagery is more effective at selling merchandise than movie tickets. Another problem lays in the fact that this aspect of Disney had essentially alienated half the population—namely, adolescent and teenage boys, who were as lucrative a market as the next. Hence, it was not a coincidence, as others have noted, that Disney’s Tangled (2010) emphasized the male’s perspective, particularly in the promotion, about as much as film based on Rapunzel could.
This brings us back to Tron. In the entire history of the Disney company, very few remotely recognizable properties in the Vault could be realistically considered more favorable to the male demographic than Tron. This is especially true when you take Pixar’s recent innovations out of the equation, a brand that’s been as much in tension, as in collaboration, with Disney’s for the last two decades. The others, 20,000 Leagues under the Sea and Black Hole, are appropriately slated for remakes. This is significant because reusing existing theatrical properties is key to Disney’s success, and has been since Disneyland in the 1950s. It’s not that Disney couldn’t come up with new properties to attract boys, but the appeal of using Tron is that it could also triangulate the nostalgia of the father, just as princess films triangulate the nostalgia of the mother. Will it work? Who knows.
But Tron: Legacy, in retrospect, is really as much a traditional Disney film as something more self-evident, such as the fairy tale Tangled. Moreover, it’s better suited to Disney’s style than the (truly groundbreaking) original was. Since the “glory” days of Walt, nearly every one of their successful theatrical films has depended on 1) the shameless nostalgia of a pre-existing fan base (Tron fans from the 1980s); 2) the prominent exploitation of technological innovation (Disney 3D); 3) the presence of hit music which can thrive with, or without, the movie itself (the Daft Punk score); 4) the benefit and familiarity of transmedia ubiquity (videogames, comic books, TV shows); and 5) the white noise of endless cross-promotion. In this regard, Tron’s return—narrative incoherence and all—makes perfect sense. And while the new film may have few fans over the age of 18, we may wish to wait a generation or two before deciding whether Disney made the right choice to bring Flynn and Co. back out of the Vault.Monday, March 21, 2011
New Introduction's Introduction
Hollywood history is littered with racist artifacts—but they are not always so lost, and their occasional endurance can tell us as much about media industry practices and racial relations in the present as the time in which they were first made. Disney’s Song of the South (1946) is today one such seemingly forgotten film, another racist relic from a cinematic past filled with no shortage of anachronistic and offensive depictions. As with many such films, it is tempting to toss Song of the South back into the dustbin of Hollywood history. The ideologically conservative Disney Corporation itself—never one to pass up a chance at exploiting older properties—has refused to re-release it to American audiences for over 25 years. On a first mention, the name itself may not even ring a bell. Yet mention Brer Rabbit, the “Tar Baby,” Uncle Remus (James Baskett) or “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah,” and suddenly many people remember that they once were quite familiar with the film, or at least with one of its many textual reiterations (Golden Books, Disneyland records, Disneyland television episodes, etc.).
For its part, Song of the South depicts Southern plantation life in the 19th Century, a time marked by unimaginable cruelty, as instead a white musical utopia. Based loosely on the 19th Century literary stories of Joel Chandler Harris, Song of the South mixed live-action footage of Uncle Remus, the kindly ex-slave, and his seemingly idyllic life on a Southern plantation, with animated sequences of Brer Rabbit outsmarting Brer Fox and Brer Bear. Despite being a landmark achievement in cost-cutting hybrid animation, early audiences initially rejected its racial insensitivities, in the wake of World War II, as well as its low-budget aesthetic, on the heels of more polished Disney productions like Snow White and Pinocchio. Yet Song of the South hardly disappeared after modest releases in the 1940s and 1950s. In fact, for a particular period as recently as the 1970s and 1980s, this offensive film was actually extremely popular. At the height of the “White Backlash” against the Civil Rights Movement and the subsequent rise of Reaganesque conservatism in the US, as well as Disney’s emergent cultural status as a powerful “family institution,” Song of the South was a considerable part of the American media landscape.
The first question one often asks now is “whatever happened to that film?” The truth, though, is that this especially problematic movie has not gone anywhere. Thanks to decades of cult followings and Disney’s own careful corporate remediation, Song of the South and the complicated histories of race and media convergence it embodies is as present and relevant as it ever was. In fact, of all the racist films from Hollywood’s past, Song of the South’s troublingly persistent survival may be the most distinctive for what it tells us today about the history of American media, its audiences, and their at times mutually-reinforcing negotiation of racist images. Beyond the limits of morbid curiosity, there is a more fascinating history of the relationship between media and race hidden here.
Song of the South has been a quietly, but instructionally resilient, film for seven decades, nearly spanning the entire lifetime of the more famous company which spawned, exploited, and eventually tossed it (officially) aside. Understanding the film’s role within the larger history of convergence culture and racial formations requires 1) documenting the ways in which Disney recirculated, repurposed and rewrote the film, 2) appreciating the diverse racial and political climates in which it appeared (and didn’t), and 3) articulating how different audiences responded to the film and its fragments via their own discursive production. This book will triangulate the cult history of Song of the South within all three contexts in order to move us closer to answering several interrelated questions: how have the textual and extratextual dynamics of “media convergence” historically interacted with larger cultural negotiations regarding racial identity in the 20th Century? How have industry strategies of remediation and forms of participatory culture affected socially-constructed notion of whiteness as mediated through, and in the reception of, representations of African-Americans in classical Hollywood films? How does the subsequent repurposing of these films in ancillary venues complicate its (and audiences’) relationship to the “original” text? How do issues such as the larger political climates in America, personal, public and commercial forms of nostalgia, and affective formations, play in further problematizing these questions? More specifically, in what ways do a powerful media institution (Disney) and its considerable, shifting, set of audiences play a sometimes mutual role in embracing, ignoring and exploiting the continuing presence of its racist past?
Embodying a wide range of contexts central to understanding these important but largely unanswered questions, Song of the South is an important text to consider not merely because of its fascinatingly unfortunate cult status as a notoriously racist film at the heart of a particularly image-conscious entertainment empire. Disney’s film has also appeared prominently both in moments of technological change and media platform transitions and in periods of cultural upheaval and racial tension. As older Hollywood films migrated—all or in part—across newer media and ancillary market channels, Disney repeatedly returned to Song of the South as a source for revenue and repurposed material despite its troubled origins and problematic history. Alternately, the film’s theatrical appearances over the last several decades always closely reflected white America’s racial consciousness, and lack thereof. Not surprisingly, then, fragments of the old Brer Rabbit film still exist in a variety of forms to this day. At a time when the future-oriented, vaguely utopian, logic of both convergence culture and post-racial whiteness suggest, even at times insist, that audiences forget the larger history of media practices underlining both, A Frown Upside Down instead seeks to illuminate the powerful ways in which the history of media convergence has alternatingly intensified, shifted and dissipated representations of racism and constructions of whiteness.
Friday, February 18, 2011
A Frown Upside Down

I'm happy to announce that my manuscript, tentatively A Frown Upside Down / Race, Convergence and the Hidden Histories of Disney's Song of the South, has been accepted at the University of Texas Press. I have a few more important revisions ahead, but the entire final manuscript and images will be due to the press in June. Thus, it should be in print within a year or so.
I'm very proud to be working with Texas--in addition to their long commitment to books on Critical Race Studies and on Disney, they also published one of my old IU committee members' books, Christopher Anderson's Hollywood TV, which includes a chapter that is for my money the best thing ever written on the original Disneyland television program, and arguably one of the key foundational texts in TV studies.
My book will be an illuminating and often troubling historical narrative about America in the latter half of the 20th Century, focused specifically on the ways in which media audiences and producers negotiated the resiliency of racist imagery across multiple platform shifts (film, television, books, records, internet, home video technologies) and racial climates (post-WWII Civil Rights movement, the White Backlash, "post-race" Reaganism). It also offers a distinctive history of the Disney Company, thinking about how crucial seemingly secondary markets, such as re-releases and the ancillary revenue channels, dating back to the 1920s, were to Disney's overall success, as well as the post-1950s reinvention of the Disney brand. It is "about" Song of the South only to the extent that particularly striking moments of reappearance--this film's disturbing resiliency throughout the Disney media empire that continues to this day--speak to the core of such larger industrial, cultural and historical reception issues (though it is also by far the most comprehensive and accurate account of the film's too often distorted distribution and reception history).
The idea began as far back as 2002, so its been a long time coming. The bulk of it was written, of course, as my dissertation from Indiana University, on which I worked from approximately 2007 until my defense in Dec. of 2009, under the guidance of my adviser Barb Klinger and committee members Christopher Anderson, Purnima Bose, Karen Bowdre and Joan Hawkins. In late spring, early summer, of 2010, I revised it quite a bit more, before turning to the Anderson project (I think I'll blog in more detail about the actual brainstorm and writing process when the final version is submitted). I first submitted the proposal to Texas in September and by November the full manuscript was being evaluated and sent out to readers. In retrospect, this process was relatively quick (especially compared to some past experiences).
I really didn't think it would take over five years before I'd publish another book. The last few years have been sobering. Partly because I didn't have perspective on the whole thing--how truly hard it is to publish a book--and partly because I've been working and writing non-stop since then. At one point in 2007, even, I had the option to publish another manuscript at one press (I had even signed the contract), but I pulled out at the last minute because everything about that situation didn't feel right. I'm glad my writing career has worked out this way. I'm finally putting something out there that I am both truly proud of, and that I believe accurately reflects my scholarly interests at this point in my career.
I might blog more about the ideas in A Frown Upside Down in the next few months, since I'll be spending a lot of time thinking through how to say what it is I'm saying. The key revision will be a largely new introduction, which I am excited to write. The bulk of the manuscript itself is strong--with one exception, I love every chapter on its own. But its been tough in a variety of environments selling the overall points I'm making, and so it will take some time to make sure I finally get it right.
peace,
js
Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Strangers in Our Own Land
My current project, Strangers in Our Own Land: Images of Hawai’i, Racial Utopia, and Leisure Culture in American Media, 1935-1970, will involve constructing a historical narrative of media representations of Hawai’i during this period, focusing closely on how the military presence, industrial promotional strategies, and mediated images of racial identity and consumerist nostalgia served as key reading strategies for a wide range of mainland audiences through the decades.
My dissertation, A Frown Upside Down/ The Affective, Cultural and Convergence Histories of Disney’s Song of the South, originally set out to document how “convergence culture” has a longer and more ambivalent history than often suggested. This research used the fascinating and disturbing history of Disney’s most notorious film to explore how media audiences and industries negotiated the persistence of offensive racial representations through decades of participatory culture, careful repurposing and shifting cultural politics. First released in 1946, Song is most famous today for its Oscar-winning song “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah,” and the story of Brer Rabbit and the Tar Baby. Although it broke modest technological ground for mixing live-action and animation, the film was rejected by critics and audiences for its anachronistic post-WWII representations of idyllic Southern plantations and subservient African-Americans.
Yet Disney continued to re-release the film periodically until 1986, while also heavily repurposing the transmediated property—children’s books, television episodes, records, VHS tapes, theme park rides and so forth. Thus, Song’s cult following intensified during the US’s “White Backlash” in the late 1960s and 1970s, and Reaganism in the 1980s, becoming a huge box office draw late in its recirculation. Today, Song maintains a small, passionate, fan base online, despite Disney’s own refusal to re-release it to theatres, or on domestic home video formats, for over twenty years. My dissertation offered a specific history of how participatory culture, transmedia platforms and industrial shifts played a key role in the interaction with, resistance to, or complicity in, the ugly resilience of racist imagery in American media.
Continuing this interest in the cultural politics of populist 20th Century American media, my next project focuses on images of Hawai’i from the mid-1930s to the early 1970s. During this period, Hawai’i’s symbolic role in US films, books, and television shows, spoke to a powerful set of historical and cultural issues, for a specific generation of American audiences, and which incorporated, transcended, and even contradicted, the islands’ assumed role as an image of escapism. Strangers in Our Own Land will document Hawai’i’s popularity with mainland audiences through the analytical lens involving several interrelated contexts: representations of the islands pre- and post-Statehood; the practices of companies such as Dole Pineapple, United Airlines and others invested in tourist promotion of Hawai’i; images and memories of US combat and military life in the Pacific; complicated attitudes towards understanding native Hawaiian history; alternating narratives of racial tension and utopia; and the promotion and modeling of an emergent middle-class leisure culture.
Beginning with the construction of an emergent leisure culture in films such as Waikiki Wedding and Honolulu in the late 1930s, followed by the mediation of WWII and its institutionalized legacy through the 1940s and 1950s (From Here to Eternity), and culminating in the islands’ remarkable popularity in the 1960s (Elvis films and albums, Bruce Brown’s Endless Summer, CBS’s original Hawaii Five-O, James Michener’s Hawaii), Hawai’i maintained a prominent and distinctive place in the American media during the mid-20th Century, which has yet to be explored. My emphasis on how audiences and American media negotiated representations of nostalgia, leisure and war will complement the historical work done in such books as Dean MacCannell’s The Tourist: A Theory of the Leisure Class (California, 1999), Jane Desmond’s Staging Tourism: Bodies on Display from Waikiki to Sea World (Chicago, 2001), Judy Rohrer’s Haoles in Hawai’i (Hawaii, 2010) and Brian Ireland’s The US Military in Hawai’i (Palgrave, 2011). The focus will be a historical-materialist reception study that examines audience responses through various periodicals and cultural contexts—with particular attention to how these texts and audiences negotiated issues of consumerism, memory and nostalgia, race and the construction of whiteness, and the imperialist presence of US military and industry in Hawai’i.
So much of Hawai’i’s popularity stems initially from America’s participation in WWII, as well as conflicts in Korea and Southeast Asia. Numerous titles—Operation Bikini (1963), From Here to Eternity (1953), In Harm’s Way (1961)—situated images of Hawai’i in relation to combat. While many of these texts reinforced a imperialist impulse, the texts themselves negotiated representations and memories of the US’s participation in Pacific combat in sometimes ambivalent ways. Yet, even before Pearl Harbor, the plantation owners and white civilian elites in Hawai’i were dedicated to rebranding the territory from sugar industries to a major tourism destination. Thus, a second context is the industrial history of the Islands’ promotion, and the emergence of Hawai’i in relation to an American leisure culture, rooted in part in a post-war middle class and the sudden availability of affordable airfare. Finally, a particularly crucial theme is the representation of inter-racial relationships in these texts. Despite a disturbing history of US colonialism and racial tension (such as the Massey Murder in 1931), Hawai’i’s image historically was a place which embraced multiculturalism and racial diversity outside the prejudices of the mainland. This symbolism became re-appropriated in media of the late 1950s and 1960s as a metaphor for the mainland’s own negotiation of racial politics during the height of the Civil Rights Movement.
Friday, January 7, 2011
Monthly Progress

Today I finished a complete draft of the last chapter, on There Will Be Blood, meaning that essentially I have completed a complete draft of my book on Anderson, tentatively titled Blossoms & Blood (I will rewrite the chapters a bit in the next month or so, and I keep going back and forth on whether or not I want to include a conclusion, but it is largely finished).
After a month of reading everything I could find on the subject, I started writing the manuscript in mid-August. For about a month or so in October and into early November, I started to hit a wall for a number of reasons, but otherwise I've been pretty focused on it the whole time. When everything really is done, I'll take some more time to reflect on that process, which in a way really stretches as far back as 2003.
I'll probably start sending out proposals in Feb (partly to have time to revise and partly with the hopes of being to include some good news on the dissertation in the meantime). Along those lines, one may have noticed that I've pulled a lot of the content off the blog for both Blossoms and A Frown--I fully intend to start bringing both those projects to an end in the next few months, with the expectation that by summer I will be back to my massive Hawai'i project.
The whole thing is about 106K words, which is only about 4 off of the final draft of A Frown Upside Down. I'd like to say its near time for a break, but I know that once I finish this for good, it will probably be time for a few more last minute revisions of A Frown Upside Down, and then . . . . wait for it . . . . back to Haunted Nerves. I am nothing if not persistent.
Friday, October 29, 2010
Tron Night

Last night, I participated in Tron Night, a promotional gimmick to build buzz and anticipation for Disney’s big tent pole Christmas season film, Tron Legacy. Like a similar stunt two summers ago for Cameron’s now record-breaking Avatar (both the preview and movie I wasn’t impressed by), Tron Night consisted of approximately 20 minutes of footage—a collection of about 5 or 6 disconnected scenes from the first half of the movie. Unlike Avatar, I came away very impressed by what I saw.
Last year’s preview was such a huge letdown, so maybe my standards were lower this time. The effects of Avatar looked nice, but I left with that Ferngully-vibe that later marred the film for a lot of people who dared to question Lord Cameron (as a fan of Aliens, Terminator, and even The Abyss and Titanic, I was especially disappointed after the long wait for his latest project). For all the marketing and promotion of how Avatar would revolutionize the ontological nature of cinema itself, I found the 3D surprisingly underwhelming and the whole look of the film was just plain, well, fake. I don’t know another word for it—I just didn’t feel a part of its world (in both senses of the phrase) for a second. It wasn’t just the blue skin and other design features of the Navi and their fellow inhabitants of Pandora that looked fake—it was how, even beyond that, they didn’t look photorealistic or three-dimensional at all. Instead, they had the bland 2D flatness of a fancy cartoon drawing instead of the convincing depth and life of, say, Golem in Lord of the Rings. The Navi looked so unrealistic that it made the indexical reality of the rest of the movie feel off for me.
And when I saw the final version months later with an open mind, it was just more of the same fakeness, structured around a clichéd, predictable plot that was about an hour longer than it needed to be. I know there were a lot of people, mostly teenagers, who genuinely loved Avatar (but let’s see how they feel about it in ten years), but its success was really due to a huge financial investment in technology upfront, an elaborate marketing campaign that repeatedly sold the film’s questionably “groundbreaking” technology, and all different kinds of ridiculous ticket inflation (3D prices, IMAX prices, even the average general admission cost is double what it was when Titanic was released 13 yrs ago). The movie itself was a whole lotta blah, and the extended preview telegraphed it.
But there were no such reservations about Tron Legacy, which may or may not turn out to be a good movie. But, of course, a big caveat: I am a huge fan of the original Tron, which was more technologically groundbreaking in how it redefined “cinema” than anything Avatar ever did. Cameron’s film did nothing especially innovative in 3D cinema, digital effects, or the IMAX format—what it did was combine them so completely at a level of spectacle and narrative unlike anything before it (but, hey, when you are “King of the World,” it’s a lot easier to afford that kind of “innovation” [$$$] in the first place). The original Tron took film apart—literally—and put it back together again. Much was made of how Tron contained the first ever completely computer-generated scenes in feature-length film history; but it was remarkable in other ways too. The film was shot on 70mm stock so that artists could go in and modified the look of the movie frame-by-frame with backlighting, hand drawings and so forth. Tiny details that would take a digital effects artist a few seconds to do today took months, even years, back then.
Its achievement was quite literally the whole history of movie effects, side-by-side with the future of movie effects simultaneously. Tron the movie itself was the technological innovation for its time; Avatar was just the most effective exploiter of other technological innovations (there was a reason Cameron spent a decade off making IMAX and 3D documentaries before returning to feature-length narrative films). Tron was not a big hit when it first appeared—partly because of intense marketplace competition in science fiction in 1982 (ET, Star Trek II, Blade Runner, etc.)—but also because it was too far ahead of its time. Neither audiences, nor perhaps the computer effects themselves, were yet ready for what Tron was trying to do.
My own relationship to Tron of course is not only a form of technological admiration (one that only grows as I come to better understand the process of filmmaking more with each passing year), but also a deeply affective and nostalgic one. But it’s weird—I don’t remember watching the film in theatres as a kid (I would have been four), and in fact the first time I ever remember watching it in its entirety was when I was in my 20s and I picked it up on DVD. But it spoke to something in me. For one thing, I remember watching the “Light Cycle” and other scenes countless times on the Disney Channel as a kid (this was back when the premium cable channel just recycled older content rather than offered any new programming, and I first saw a lot of Disney’s extensive catalog that way).
So I do remember watching a great deal of it when I was young—just not the complete movie. Moreover, watching Tron a couple decades later, I was thrown back not only to an era of early CGI that was oddly reassuring in its primitive state, but also to a video game culture structured around the old-fashioned “Game Arcade” that was ubiquitous when I was a child, but which was already quickly passing in the 21st Century home gaming era of Playstations and Xboxes. I remembered playing the Tron arcade game as a kid, as well as numerous others from the period. Tron spoke retrospectively to that huge part of my youth—where I would go off to the Mall arcade for an hour with a few bucks in hand while my parents were shopping.
I don’t know that the story of Tron ever really particularly sucked me in—the standard “technology is overtaking the world” kind of sci-fi narrative. Even Bridges’ Flynn was a strangely uninvolving character, an aloof jerk (and unevenly acted by Bridges in a rare uncharacteristic performance), while Bruce Boxleitner was too predictably bland to make for an interesting lead. Rather, it was the atmosphere of both 1980s arcades and the seductively beautiful spectacle of the ENCOM Mainframe world itself that appealed to me.
I don’t think that I ever felt “immersed” into that diegetic world, but I always found its sterile beauty transcendent and even soothing in its own nascent way. It became one of those “late night” movies for me—the ones (usually horror or science fiction) that I watched at night when I couldn’t sleep. They helped me sleep not because they were boring, but because they were, and are, so effectively atmospheric that I was taken out of my own world and into another just enough to calm me down and drift away. In a sense, I got lost in the spectacle of Tron.
And, based on what I saw last night, Tron Legacy takes that feeling to a whole new level—is it as groundbreaking as the original? Of course not. I’m not sure it does anything really technologically advanced. But what it does well is maintain the clean, barren, symmetrical look of the original, with the attendant iconography, while also giving the Mainframe world just enough grit, fog and shadows to feel like a more three-dimensional, and even more quietly sinister, world. Whereas the original Tron was simply alien in its mise-en-scene, the new one is more ambiguous, ominous and absorbing.
You feel like you’re in a world that is straddling the line between science-fiction and horror, while still retaining the original’s techno-beauty (it must be said here that Daft Punk’s score sounds simply amazing—particularly in a sequence where several Recognizers float across the digital landscape after picking Sam up—and will be worth the price of admission alone. It matches the look, sound and feel of Tron’s world while also being unlike anything we heard in the original).
Of course, this new sense of immersion, unlike the first Tron, is also due to the wise addition of 3D. But I didn’t find the 3D effect all that engaging on its own—in fact, it had the same two-plane effect that I perceived when I saw Avatar. There are objects in the foreground, while the background often felt like a flat wall, particularly involving scenes of dialogue. But overall it was effective in selling Sam’s new experience in his dad’s world.
The early “real life” scenes shown—Sam being visited at his apartment (inside a cargo shipping container) by Alan (a welcome sight in Boxleitner again), and then him exploring his Dad’s abandoned arcade (lovingly recreated from the original) were presented in the usual 2D, leading me to assume that only scenes inside the ENCOM mainframe are done in 3D. This would be a clever creative (and well as cost-conscious) move, if true.
So, what scenes did I see? The first two, as I noted above, involved Sam in the real world. I hope Boxleitner has a bigger role in the full version (the first scene of Alan’s visit was listed as Scene 20, so hopefully there’s more backstory involved in how we get from Tron to Tron Legacy). Sam’s coffee table is littered with motorcycle magazines, clearly a daredevil and a bike junkie that foreshadows the Light Cycle scenes. The next scene involves Sam discovering his dad’s basement office beneath the arcade, appropriately decorated with the relevant technology from the 1980s (a nice compliment to the old school arcade games above), where—after an abrupt cut—we are left to presume he is zapped like his Dad in the original into the computer world.
We then jump ahead to the 3D stuff and a lengthy scene in the Grid where Sam is captured by a Recognizer, carried off to a processing center, fitted with the appropriate outfits and memory discs by four female programs, and then sent off to fight in a Disc game (much like Flynn’s experience in the original, minus the obvious sex appeal). After that, we jump ahead to the very end of a Light Cycle sequence, where another program—played by Olivia Wilde—helps him escape the games and the city, into a space that is presumably “off-line.” Then, she takes Sam to the “safehouse” where he (and the audience) are re-introduced to Flynn, played with a suitably zen-like gruffiness by Jeff Bridges (this time channeling a mellower, more soft-spoken Lebowski).
This last scene was my favorite—I don’t know if I’m sold on the actor overall, but in this scene Garrett Holmund really sells Sam’s emotional state at seeing his father for the first time in 20 years, it is genuinely moving, while Bridges’ nails Flynn’s strange ambivalence as both a father genuinely happy to be reunited with his son, but also as a man who has been trapped in a networked, digitized world for so long that he no longer clearly has the interpersonal, human capacity to relate to other people in a compassionate way (thus making Sam’s heartbreak all the more devastating). It could be a great performance.
The extended preview ends with Flynn looking out over the world from the vantage point of his safe house (in a vision of the city directly evoking a similar shot in the original), and then transitions over the standard theatrical teaser trailer that many people have already seen. In fact, all the scenes in Tron Night felt like extended versions of the moments we’ve already seen in previews. There is one quick reference to “Tron” himself (which was Alan’s program in the original), but there’s no clear sense of what, if any, role the title character plays in this sequel. There is also no real sense of the film’s larger plot—we don’t know what’s at stake—online or in the real world—for Sam, Flynn, Alan or anyone else this time around.
The preview worked for me because it successfully appealed to, and intensified, the two things I love about the original: nostalgia for various media technologies and cultures from the 1980s, and the techno-beauty of Encom’s mainframe. And the role of Flynn, plus the reappearance of Bridges and Boxleitner, grounds the film in such a way that it feels like a true continuation of the original, rather than just another half-brained “reboot,” “reimagining,” or some other hollow, quick money-grab on the backs of another maxed-out transmedia franchise. So, I’m on board.
End of line.